| NCAAB | 02/26 00:00 | 122 | Mount Union v Otterbein | L | 75-57 | |
| NCAAB | 02/22 20:00 | - | Baldwin Wallace v Otterbein | L | 61-60 | |
| NCAAB | 02/20 00:00 | - | John Carroll v Otterbein | L | 88-67 | |
| NCAAB | 02/15 19:00 | - | Otterbein v Muskingum | W | 88-68 | |
| NCAAB | 02/13 00:00 | - | Otterbein v Ohio Northern | W | 83-66 | |
| NCAAB | 02/08 19:00 | - | Mount Union v Otterbein | L | 99-72 | |
| NCAAB | 02/06 00:00 | - | Otterbein v Wilmington College | L | 80-85 | |
| NCAAB | 02/02 00:30 | - | Capital v Otterbein | L | 74-61 | |
| NCAAB | 01/30 00:00 | - | Otterbein v Marietta | L | 54-76 | |
| NCAAB | 01/25 20:00 | - | Otterbein v Heidelberg | W | 62-57 | |
| NCAAB | 01/23 00:00 | - | Ohio Northern v Otterbein | W | 79-81 | |
| NCAAB | 01/18 19:00 | - | Otterbein v Mount Union | L | 67-79 | |
| NCAAB | 01/16 00:00 | - | Wilmington College v Otterbein | L | 71-61 | |
| NCAAB | 01/11 19:00 | - | Otterbein v Baldwin Wallace | L | 68-76 | |
| NCAAB | 01/09 00:00 | - | Otterbein v John Carroll | L | 59-76 | |
| NCAAB | 01/04 19:00 | - | Muskingum v Otterbein | W | 71-86 | |
| NCAAB | 12/29 19:00 | - | Otterbein v Albion Britons | L | 54-80 | |
| NCAAB | 12/29 00:00 | - | Bluffton v Otterbein | L | 70-50 | |
| NCAAB | 12/14 20:00 | - | Heidelberg v Otterbein | L | 71-59 | |
| NCAAB | 12/08 00:00 | - | Otterbein v Capital | L | 58-64 | |
| NCAAB | 12/05 00:00 | - | Marietta v Otterbein | L | 78-56 | |
| NCAAB | 11/27 00:00 | - | Waynesburg v Otterbein | W | 44-67 | |
| NCAAB | 11/23 20:00 | - | Denison v Otterbein | L | 70-69 | |
| NCAAB | 11/16 23:00 | - | Oberlin Yeomen v Otterbein | L | 70-59 |